One of the most common questions I hear from retirees is:
“What accounts should I withdraw from first in retirement?”
At first glance, the answer seems simple. Many financial websites suggest following a standard rule:
- Withdraw from taxable accounts first.
- Then withdraw from traditional IRAs and 401(k)s.
- Leave Roth accounts for last.
While that strategy can work in some situations, it's far from a one-size-fits-all solution.
In today's retirement landscape, factors such as tax law changes, Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs), Medicare premium thresholds, Social Security taxation, and legacy goals all influence the ideal withdrawal sequence. The order in which you draw income can potentially impact your after-tax retirement income for decades.
For many retirees, the question isn't simply "Which account should I withdraw from first?"
It's "How can I create income while managing taxes throughout retirement?"
Let's explore the factors that matter most in 2026 and 2027.
The Three Main Types of Retirement Assets
Before determining withdrawal order, it's important to understand the tax treatment of your accounts.
Taxable Accounts
Examples include:
- Brokerage accounts
- Joint investment accounts
- Individual investment accounts
- Bank savings accounts
When withdrawals occur from these accounts, only gains may be taxable. Long-term capital gains often receive more favorable tax treatment than ordinary income.
Tax-Deferred Accounts
Examples include:
- Traditional IRAs
- Traditional 401(k)s
- 403(b)s
- SEP IRAs
These accounts were generally funded with pre-tax dollars.
Every dollar withdrawn typically counts as ordinary income and may increase your tax liability.
Additionally, the IRS requires withdrawals beginning at age 73 for many retirees, with age 75 applying to those born in 1960 or later under current law. [irs.gov]
Tax-Free Accounts
Examples include:
- Roth IRAs
- Roth 401(k)s
Qualified withdrawals are generally tax-free.
Roth IRAs also offer the benefit of no required minimum distributions during the original owner's lifetime. [irs.gov]
The Traditional Withdrawal Strategy
Historically, planners often recommended:
Step 1: Withdraw From Taxable Accounts
This allows retirement accounts to continue growing tax-deferred or tax-free.
Step 2: Use Traditional Retirement Accounts
Once taxable assets have been depleted, withdrawals shift to IRAs and 401(k)s.
Step 3: Preserve Roth Accounts
Roth assets may continue growing tax-free and can provide flexibility later in retirement.
This approach remains popular because it is straightforward.
However, simple isn't always optimal.
Why the "Traditional" Approach Can Be Costly
Retirement planning has changed dramatically over the last decade.
Many retirees today have:
- Larger IRA balances
- Longer life expectancies
- Multiple income sources
- Roth conversion opportunities
- Medicare premium considerations
- Estate planning goals
As a result, delaying IRA withdrawals until RMD age can sometimes create problems later.
For example, a retiree may spend taxable assets for years while allowing a large IRA balance to continue growing.
When RMDs eventually begin, those mandatory withdrawals may:
- Increase taxable income
- Create larger tax bills
- Trigger Medicare IRMAA surcharges
- Increase taxation of Social Security benefits
In some cases, retirees who were in relatively low tax brackets during their 60s find themselves in higher brackets during their 70s.
That's why tax-efficient withdrawal planning is increasingly important.
A Better Question: What Tax Bracket Am I In Today?
Rather than focusing only on account type, many retirement income plans begin with tax bracket management.
For some retirees, it may make sense to:
- Withdraw modest amounts from traditional IRAs earlier
- Perform strategic Roth conversions
- Fill lower tax brackets before RMDs begin
- Reduce future tax burdens
The goal isn't necessarily to minimize taxes this year.
The goal is often to manage taxes over your entire retirement.
This is known as lifetime tax planning, and it can have a significant impact on retirement income sustainability.
Common Withdrawal Scenarios
Scenario 1: Recent Retiree Before Social Security
A retiree ages 62-67 may have:
- No earned income
- No Social Security benefits yet
- Lower taxable income than they will have later
This may create an opportunity to draw from traditional IRA assets strategically or complete Roth conversions while remaining in a favorable tax bracket.
Scenario 2: Retiree Approaching RMD Age
A retiree with a large IRA balance may face substantial future RMDs.
Waiting until age 73 could result in forced taxable income at a time when they no longer need the money.
Careful planning beforehand may help reduce future RMD impacts.
Scenario 3: Legacy-Focused Retirees
Some investors intend to leave assets to children or grandchildren.
In these situations, preserving Roth assets could be beneficial because qualified withdrawals are generally tax-free.
Withdrawal sequencing may be adjusted to align with family goals.
Healthcare Costs and Medicare Matter Too
Many retirees are surprised to learn that withdrawal decisions can affect Medicare costs.
Higher income can trigger Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amounts (IRMAA), which increase Medicare Part B and Part D premiums.
A withdrawal strategy that looks efficient on paper could unintentionally increase future healthcare expenses.
That's another reason why retirement income planning should consider more than just account balances.
Our Advanced Time Segmentation Approach
At Malecki Financial Group, we believe withdrawal planning should be personalized.
One of the tools available through our planning process is Advanced Time Segmentation, a retirement income methodology available through Cetera that helps clients organize assets based on when they are expected to be needed.
Rather than viewing retirement assets as one large pool of money, Advanced Time Segmentation helps create distinct time horizons within a retirement plan.
A simplified example might include:
Short-Term Assets
Funds intended for near-term income needs.
Mid-Term Assets
Assets positioned to support future spending several years down the road.
Long-Term Assets
Assets designed for long-term growth and future income opportunities.
By mapping assets to different retirement time horizons, we can evaluate:
- Which accounts may be best suited for current withdrawals
- Which accounts may benefit from continued growth
- Tax implications of various withdrawal sequences
- The potential impact of market volatility on future income needs
- Long-term sustainability objectives
Most importantly, Advanced Time Segmentation helps create a personalized withdrawal strategy rather than relying on generic rules of thumb.
The same withdrawal order that works well for one retiree may be completely inappropriate for another.
Factors such as age, tax bracket, account balances, retirement goals, Social Security timing, healthcare considerations, and legacy objectives all play a role.
A personalized plan can help retirees make more informed decisions regarding when and how retirement assets may be used throughout retirement.
The Right Withdrawal Order Depends on Your Situation
The reality is that there is no universally correct withdrawal sequence.
For one retiree, the best strategy may be:
- Taxable first
- IRA second
- Roth last
For another, it may involve:
- Strategic IRA withdrawals
- Partial Roth conversions
- Coordinated Social Security timing
- Ongoing tax bracket management
The retirement withdrawal decision is often less about finding a single correct answer and more about creating a strategy that aligns with your personal goals.
Key Takeaways
When determining which accounts to withdraw from first in retirement:
✅ Understand the tax treatment of each account.
✅ Consider future RMDs, not just current taxes.
✅ Evaluate Medicare and Social Security implications.
✅ Look at lifetime tax efficiency rather than year-to-year taxes.
✅ Avoid relying solely on generic withdrawal rules.
✅ Consider a personalized retirement income plan using Advanced Time Segmentation.
Ready to Build Your Retirement Income Strategy?
No two retirements are alike, and neither are withdrawal strategies.
At Malecki Financial Group, we help retirees evaluate tax-efficient withdrawal approaches using personalized retirement income planning tools, including Advanced Time Segmentation.
If you'd like to discuss how your retirement accounts, tax situation, and income goals fit together, contact our team to schedule a retirement income review.
This article is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as tax, legal, or investment advice. Consult with qualified professionals regarding your specific situation.